Minecraft Middle Earth is a Minecraft community that recreates the world described by JRR Tolkien and his writings. Everyone can participate in organized events in which we collaborate to create major landmarks, terrain, caves, castles, towns, farms and more.
To get started, visit The New Player Guide
Joining the server can be done straight away, but you will have to pass the New Player Quiz. Use the The New Player Guide to get acquainted with our community.
That would be pretty cool. Hmm....I wonder if Jord's lore wisdom would also apply to the power of river currents?I just had an awesome idea: the Osgiliath-stone should be placed somewhere in the Anduin!
It was apparently a huge palantir; one man couldn't lift it. So if it fell into the river from the top of that tower, I'd say it would stick pretty well in the mud.That would be pretty cool. Hmm....I wonder if Jord's lore wisdom would also apply to the power of river currents?
Well, I'm not sure exactly what the stones were made of, but whatever it was, it was pretty heavy. (the stone Wormtongue threw out the window cracked the stairs into Orthanc) Also, this stone was too big for just one person at a time to carry it, and nearly 1/3 of that tower is missing. Wherever it fell, the palantir on the top floor would not be near the foot of the tower, and lore says it fell in the river...But the water could have slow down the stone, and then it could have been taken further by the stream. Actually, the stone would certainly have been founded if it was just at the foot of the tower... Plus, the tower isn't right above the rivern, so the Palantír should have firtstly fallen on the island and then rolled to the Anduin.
Or it could have been taken by someone outside of the tower for some reason, this person could have been attacked, have dropped the stone and then it rolled to the Anduin.
That's exactly what I'm saying.Wherever it fell, the palantir on the top floor would not be near the foot of the tower
In my two hypotheses, the Palantír finishes in the river.and lore says it fell in the river
Seems like the two options for the osgiliath-stone would beBut the water could have slow down the stone, and then it could have been taken further by the stream. Actually, the stone would certainly have been founded if it was just at the foot of the tower... Plus, the tower isn't right above the rivern, so the Palantír should have firtstly fallen on the island and then rolled to the Anduin.
Or it could have been taken by someone outside of the tower for some reason, this person could have been attacked, have dropped the stone and then it rolled to the Anduin.
I still think that it could reasonably be placed half buried in mud as an Easter egg somewhere. (Half slabs maybe)I saw you finished the Palantír tower, so... what about the stone itself?
But this thing was a massive stone. It's very unlikely it would have made its way very far down the river at all, probably not even outside of Osgiliath before being buried in mud.You could place up further in Anduin, outside Osgiliath, or even in Belegaer.
And the Anduin is a "massive" river. In my opinion, it makes sens. But not required either.But this thing was a massive stone. It's very unlikely it would have made its way very far down the river at all, probably not even outside of Osgiliath before being buried in mud.
Well, if it required several men to lift it, I bet that if it fell into the river it could reasonably weigh enough to sink to the bottom almost instantly into the mud, at that very spot. If anyone argues that someone would have already found it by now, we could just tell them that in real life, it wouldn't be so easy to get to it. After all, our Anduin doesn't even have a current.And the Anduin is a "massive" river. In my opinion, it makes sens. But not required either.
It doesn't matter how big the Anduin is, the stone required multiple people to pick it up and move it. It's a massive, heavy rock. It wouldn't be carried far at all.And the Anduin is a "massive" river. In my opinion, it makes sens. But not required either.
We use cookies and similar technologies for the following purposes:
Do you accept cookies and these technologies?
We use cookies and similar technologies for the following purposes:
Do you accept cookies and these technologies?