Finished Dol Amroth

[Beathaven]

Team: CarFace
Player: MrScarface981

So it's Mrs Car Face? I've read it wrong all along...

 

[xSimplezx]

Team: xSimplezx
Player: xSimplezx

 

[_Luk]

Team: xSimplezx
Player: xSimplezx

Plot 20

 

[TestofOne]

Is there anyway I could get some feedback on my plot? I finished it rather fast and don't know what to do now. So any advice ideas tips would be most willkomen. I is plot 15 Tower guard.

 

[DSESGH]

Is there anyway I could get some feedback on my plot? I finished it rather fast and don't know what to do now. So any advice ideas tips would be most willkomen. I is plot 15 Tower guard.

Just ask anybody you trust

 

[TestofOne]

Well thanks for volunteering dsesgh

 

[Bombur8]

I would need someone to place the forbidden blocks on mine (is plot 16). Don't forget the sources . Color code above the build!









Also, some missing powerrails on the already installed gatehouse (second picture is from the floating model):

 

[Bombur8]

Firstly, many thanks for placing the blocks. There were just a problem with the water in the central pool (which made a kind of roof instead of filling it) , so I tried to fix it by myself but I did a few mistakes and now I need some more water to fix stream derps .

Also, is it possible to fill the cauldrons on top of the towers and in the kitchen?

EDIT : It's OK, I succeeded to fix the water, but I still need the caldrons .

 

[_Luk]

REGISTRATION CLOSED

Stay tuned

 

[Demonataz]

Congratulations
To our two finalists: Plot 9 Bearly-a-team and Plot 12 LostBanshee
​

I will be Pm'ing both teams on the forums with feedback so that they can make adjustments, with the final gate being chosen on the 23rd of November

Thank you to all those who participated, and we hope you enjoyed it.

 

[Bombur8]

How the fuck isn't number 5 finalist oO ? Well, anyway, I personally congratulate its builder(s) ! And congratulations too to Bearly-a-team and Lost Banshee !




Also, can I have some staff feedback on mine ? In order to improve my skills.

 

[Aule_]

number 5 is very impressive, but i think the reason it hasn't been chosen, is because it doesn't feel like a city wall gatehouse. it's more like the citadel gatehouse, and as this comp is for the city gatehouse design, I believe that's why it wasn't chosen. but all in all 5 is very very good. and kudos to the finalists too

 

[Beathaven]

Number 13 is beautiful. I can't understand why it isn't implented yet!

 

[Eriol_Eandur]

...because it doesn't feel like a city wall gatehouse. it's more like the citadel gatehouse, ...

The contest is not for the city wall gatehouse but for the gate of the military section, which is some kind of citadel. Possibly I am wrong with that, but nice to hear that it looks the way I wanted to. Thanks to you and Bombur for positve feedback. I think my gate is possibly a bit too large (In my opinion the size is necessary for a realistic portcuills with a lifting mechanism on top). Also the special design with roof would determine the style of the surrounding buildings which is possibly problematic (I should have asked someone about that in time).

To Bombur: I like your gate, especially your great swan, maybe such a swan could be used for wall decoration in Prince Imrahil's hall.

And congratulations to the finalists! I believe we will have a very good gate next week.

 

[Will_em]

Ok for the staff feedback so many of you are asking, you can either post it on the artist/builder feedback thread (http://www.mcmiddleearth.com/threads/artist-builder-feedback.164/) or just pm me or another staff to ask for feedback. I don't think posting in here is the best way to ensure you get some feedback.

 

[_Luk]

A Big Congratiolation To Plot 12 LostBanshee(@Lostbanshee )
for being the Winner of the Dol Amroth Gate Contest.​

The Gate can be checked out at /warp Dol Amroth now!
Also a thank to all the particpants, it wouldn't be possible without you.

​

 

[el_schnarcho]

Congrats to you @Lostbanshee even though it was a close call for me... there is always a next time

 

[Lostbanshee]

thank you and your gate is amazing too. you'll see something you built implemented soon I'm sure!

 

[Bombur8]

I have some suggestions:
The road junction with the newly pasted gate looks rather strange, I propose to move it one block left:

This doesn't look very good either:

In a defensive perspective, I think it would be wise to add a gate somewhere on this road:

 

[Demonataz]

The road to the gate will be altered, it was done as an approximate location before the walls had been pasted.