Will_Slams
Worthy of Mordor
- Credits
- 0
- XP
- 0
Minecraft Middle Earth is a Minecraft community that recreates the world described by JRR Tolkien and his writings. Everyone can participate in organized events in which we collaborate to create major landmarks, terrain, caves, castles, towns, farms and more.
To get started, visit The New Player Guide
Joining the server can be done straight away, but you will have to pass the New Player Quiz. Use the The New Player Guide to get acquainted with our community.
I completely agree,I would just like to point out that having repairs spread across the wall like this is not realistic. I think denethor would have been slightly more intelligent than getting people to repair 8 random spots along the walls because:
1. It is not defensively sound as if you just have small bits, the enemy can just walk around the wall! If you have one or two longer bits they will have to make a longer detour.
2. Linking on to my first point - why put defenses away from a path and facing all directions? Large amounts of troops would travel along a path, not through fields. Also, defense would be stationed facing mordor and south near harlong along the anduin, as those are where the main attacks would originate.
3. From a more practical rather than defensive point of view, I cannot see, in a short time, builders being sent with large amounts of bricks and equipment through fields. It is more probable they repair the areas around major roads than in the middle of nowhere or on a small path...
Anyway, that's just my two cents,
-nat
I completely agree,
It may be good to simply have 2, maybe 3, areas of work strategically placed against incoming attacks. One would assume the areas nearest to Osgiliath would be points of contention and thereby may need to be fortified first before securing other openings
Alright then. Lemme have a day or two to figure this out, but that does sound like a better idea.I completely agree,
It may be good to simply have 2, maybe 3, areas of work strategically placed against incoming attacks. One would assume the areas nearest to Osgiliath would be points of contention and thereby may need to be fortified first before securing other openings
I don't think there's any specific mention of the build order. Just be sensible with it.
That is still a bit too many imo. I would suggest 2 on the Mordor-facing side and 1 southOk so, just to see what people generally think of this:
3-4 repair areas on Mordor-facing wall, and 2 areas on Harad-facing wall sound good?
Also remember, it is seventeen years before the War of the Ring, so the repairs are just getting started. They aren't really meant to keep anything out yet.
That is still a bit too many imo. I would suggest 2 on the Mordor-facing side and 1 south
That is still a bit too many imo. I would suggest 2 on the Mordor-facing side and 1 south
What about 1 on the way south end, then repairs on the Harlond gate, 2 large ones and 1 or 2 small ones on the east end, and just Forannest on the north end?But 2 larger ones..
We're not talking about the specific section ID's right now, we're talking about how many to build.I would suggest 1 or 2 instead of 3 or 4 because 3 and 4 are on the Anduin and 1 and 2 are just after Osgiliath, the main Anduin crossing place.
The Causeway Forts are those two unruined towers on the road to Osgo, right?the Harlond gate would be under repair first just for the convenience of the road. A lot of Minas Tirith's trade goods are either imported or exported through Harlond, so the road from there to the city would be well-traveled. The causeway forts would also probably be under some construction.
Let's do this thing!You can put it up to a community vote!
We use cookies and similar technologies for the following purposes:
Do you accept cookies and these technologies?
We use cookies and similar technologies for the following purposes:
Do you accept cookies and these technologies?